Have you been diagnosed with a depressive disorder?
Submitted by art on Tue, 2007-05-29 14:08.
People with MS have been reported to have a higher incidence of clinical depression. Let us know your situation.
I have MS and have been diagnosed with a depressive disorder
50% (175 votes)
I have MS and have not been diagnosed with a depressive disorder
45% (159 votes)
I don't have MS and have been diagnosed with a depressive disorder
2% (6 votes)
I don't have MS and have not been diagnosed with a depressive disorder
3% (12 votes)
Total votes: 352


Drugs caused mine
I'm better now that I'm off medications for MS (except methotrexate for it and Crohn's disease). Avonex was the worst for me. Definite cause and effect there.
Depression
I think added to the question should be What MS medication are you on. We may find the depression of so many MS suffers may be caused by the medication.
This is an important point.
This is an important point. Depression in MS may be due to a number of things:
- biological disruption of the disease in the brain/spinal cord
- psychological effect of having a chronic illness
- side effect of a drug (e.g. interferons can sometimes trigger it)
- secondary effect of symptoms (e.g. spasticity disrupting sleep)
So before going on a med to treat depression, it is worth looking into these other areas to make sure you couldn't treat it without.
***
Art Mellor, Accelerated Cure Project for MS, art-msnews -at- acceleratedcure.com
MS Medications
I've always been anxious about things in the past but it was never extreme like it is now. I'm noticing (and so has my family) that the medication (I take Rebif by the way) seems to "amplify" these emotions or anxiety. I've thought about a drug vacation - but then I remember my doctor reminding me that once I'm disabled there is nothing that can be done to reverse it... Having gone blind in the past and regaining eyesight keeps me a good patient.
not depression per se
I have PPMS, take only LDN 2 mg daily and have been diagnosed with anhedonia. According to Wiki - Anhedonia is often experienced by drug addicts following withdrawal. Seems quite logical to me - my life before MS was one long high, no drugs - just the joy of being able to do anything I wanted. Now, some bustard cut off my supply......
Keep in mind that LDN is an
Keep in mind that LDN is an opiate receptor blocker and could potentially be interfering with your "hedonia".
***
Art Mellor, Accelerated Cure Project for MS, art-msnews -at- acceleratedcure.com
opiate receptor blocker
Well spotted Art, I hadn't thought of that but I'll investigate.
Have you been diagnosed with a depressive disorder?
Watergypsy, I can really identify with your comments - I have had a similar experience - except - Recently, in the past 12 months, I had found a pretty good place via the benefit of Solumedrol and Provigil in addition to my ABCR therapy. Then - the company that runs the Rx benefits for the health insurance I am covered by, decided that monthly Solumedrol is experamental for MS, (ok for accute exacerbations - but not for one every month) and also they denied me Provigil because it was not approved for MS specifically. Fighting their decision without the benefit of these energy sources has proven tough and has left me with a diagnosis of depression and spending a lot of time in my recliner in front of the TV.
What I think is hysterical is that I am now considering switching from my ABRC treatment (which runs more than $12k a year) to Tysabri (at more than $24k a year). This, due do the fact that the Rx organization in their small minded wisdom won't cover the cheap steroid ($80) and it's admin (another $60). Penny wise and pound foolish anyone? They didn't see the humor when I raised this to their attention - leaving me further "depressed".
small minded wisdom
CD, we have the same absurdities in the UK – healthcare bosses think it much better to pay thousands per year to keep an Mser in residential care rather than allow the use of LDN at £30 per month to enable someone to stay in their own home. And we’re the ones with the cognitive problems?
Depressed all my life
It runs in my fathers side of the family. Never knew any different. Thought everyone was like me. LOL!
So mine is not MS involved. As long as I take the medication I am fine.
depression and MS
I had major depression and msjor cognitive loss long before M.S. was even considered -- though they couldn't figure out why I had them and why I didn't respond to treatment.
of course that was back in the '50s and '60s
when such was not admitted, and maybe not even considered?
depression
In my early 20's I got depressed episode (while I am normally a happy-go-lucky, positive person). Could not figure out why. Now looking back (after MS diagnosis 2yrs ago) it makes sense, hormones, flare-ups (back then not feeling good) would make the depression worse. I never realized how down I was, until my friends reminded me that it was pretty bad back then (yes, I have good friends, 15 yrs later and they are still there!). The Avonex made it worse for a while, but after severalmonths with meds it got better. Tried stopping with anti-depressants in the winter -> not a good idea, wait for the spring, tweeting birds, flowers and sun make it a lot easier to quit anti-depressants. For the past year only taking Avonex. There is a silver lining.
Depression before and after MS
I have had recurrent major depression since my teens...long before MS which struck at 46 yo as best I can tell. I was diagnosed 2 years ago at 48yo.
My depression is both genetic (mother was depressed for much of my childhood) and situational. It is also much worse in winter and became more problematic when we moved from St. Louis to the Boston area.
But MS sure didn't make my depression problems better! I started a new and challenging job within 10 days of diagnosis and my 1st 18 months after diagnosis were rocky with 5 courses of IV steroids despite Avonex. Chronic pain and crushing fatigue are my most prominent and troublesome MS symptoms. I have always been a very energetic person and scarcely missed a day of work for decades despite back problems, herniated discs and depression.
Much to my surprise and delight my depression lifted within a couple of weeks of starting Tysabri. It was bizarre and so organic! I couldn't wean my anti-depressant fast enough even though it was December which is a predictably bad time for me.
I guess my point is that depression is such a complex thing in people with MS.
I really believe there was an active biologic process going on in my brain that worsened my depression and has been alleviated by Tysabri. I did not really appreciate that Avonex was contributing but I now think it was a significant contributor to both my fatigue and depression. I have enormously less pain since starting Tysabri...which certainly makes it easier to feel cheerful. And after two years I am sort of coming to terms with this damn disease including the need to leave a career I have loved that is simply too physically demanding now.
Also I could never have survived the last two years without the support and guidance of my kind and skilled psychiatrist. I feel incredibly fortunate that I connected with him more than a year before my diagnosis.
care giver's depression?
I care for my wife is is quite incapacitated with MS; she is on a mild anti-depressant which keeps her in good spirits. Sometimes I feel depressed, but we all do sometimes. I have not been diagnosed or treated. I'd like to see more on the site for MS caregivers. Keep up ypur good work.
Ed
Depression
Ed,
Your comments concerning caregivers in my opinion is right on. I think treating depression in caregivers is a win win situation for all. I have MS but anyone who is progressive knows the stress it brings to a marriage.
Finding the cause of depression in MS people as Art mentioned is crucial. What I have found through the Support group I run and my own experience of talking with Neurologists and therapists is that many feel it is a weakness of character to be depressed and take medication, so they do not seek help for it. I understand that as I was one of those.
So when done under the care of a good doctor the whole family would do well to seek help, thus helping themselves which in turn helps the MS person. I think many of us truly understand what you are saying.
Thanks for staying involved.
Diann P.
Depression and MS
I have had PPMS for thirteen years now. I have gone from being an active person, teaching, gardening, doing printmaking sewing house cleaning, walking, etc. to sitting in a wheelchair and pecking two fingered at the computer. You should have a fifth question. Do you have MS and are you depressed but trying to cope anyway? YES For some of us more drugs is not the answer.
PPMS and Depression
I have had PPMS for 8 years and many new symtpoms keep popping up. I believe my depression comes from a number of sources. First, I have severe spasticity in my legs and it stops me from sleeping at night. Also, I have to get up to use the bathroom several times during the night. Second, the worse my symptoms get and the more debilitating the desease makes me, the more I feel like an invalid and have to rely on husband for just about everything. Not being able to do anything is very depressing and also knowing that things may get even worse doesn't help. I have learned that increased stress brings on increased symtpoms. It's hard not to get stressed out, especially in my situation with 10 grandchildren, most of whom are teenagers and 5 of them living in my home. I am not taking any prescription drugs now. I'm taking natural supplements and working with a nutritionist. It would help to communicate with others who have PPMS. I look forward to hearing from you. Let's try to encourage one another. Hope a cure comes soon for all of us.
support
Hi Maryann,
I would like to communicate with you but since I can't remember my user name I can't write you in a more direct manor. If you still want to write, please try from your end. You obviously have a better memory than me.
Helene
depression
I've had MS for 21 years and just started Copaxone. Had some anxiety mostly in dreams the first few weeks. The only time I took an anti-depressant was during menopause. I used effexor and my hot flushes went away. I got good sleep for the year I was on the medication. While depression is in my family, I have not experienced MS related depression.
Anxiety
Hi All, I was diagnosed with RRMS approx. 2 years ago and while never had any issues in the past with depression or anxiety am now having a problem with total irrational anxiety. I wonder if it's caused by the medication I take -- Rebif... Dr. gave me Lorazapam which helps to take the edge off but don't like relying on meds all the time. Wondered if anyone else was having this issue and could offer any tips or technques to help deal - losing my job because of lack of focus due to anxiety is NOT AN OPTION. Need those health benefits... :) Thank you in advance!!
severe anxiety
Cheryl,
I have not been on Rebif, but after having MS for a period of time also developed severe anxiety. My doctor put me on Klonopin and it has worked great for me. Location of lesions and brain chemicals seem to set off these problems in MS. I know it really stinks to be dependant on medications,but I look at it this way, if I were a diabetic I would have to take insulin to maintain my quality of life. So with MS all we can do at this point is maintain the best quality of life possible until that cure comes.
Yes those health benefits are everything. In fact thats a whole other issue that is of great concern to me! Anyway I hope you can ask your doctor about the Klonopin and you get relief soon.
Diann
Anxiety Issues
Thanks Diann, I appreciate it and you make a good point with the diabetes example... I'll look into the Klonopin. I am also looking into starting an exercise program hoping that will alleve some of this... It's weird because it's completely irrational anxiety and even in the moment I know it's irrational and yet it doesn't go away... Ugh!! This too shall pass - that's what I keep saying to myself. Thanks again and hope you're well...
MS / Anxiety & Exercise
Hi Cheryl, Exercise has been helpful for me - the only downside is that I dont have energy to drive the exercise and I dont get that second-wind like I used to - but when I exercise I feel better, symptoms feel more manageable. Im sure its a combination of mental and physical. Keep your positive attitude :0)
MS / Anxiety & Exercise
Hi Crystal,
Thanks. I had started walking with my Mom. We call it the "big block" which is just shy of 3 miles but it's been sporadic cuz of my energy level - my Mom is in better shape than me :(... I am hoping to get on a more routine schedule and am hoping that will improve the anxiety.
I was also entertaining thoughts of doing the MS Challenge Walk - 50 miles in 3 days - whoo hoo...
Depression/Anxiety
I was diagnosed with Major Depressive Disorder with Anxiety 6 years ago, and MS 2 years ago. I'm lucky in that my MS was diagnosed early and I have not had another episode since the diagnosis, but the depression has increased significantly since then.
Initially I was on Avonex which made me practically bedridden, and my psychiatrist had to increase the dosage of Effexor that I was taking. During this time, I began having neuropathy pain, and I ended up on Neurontin as well.
After a year of Avonex treatment, my neurologist and I decided to change treatment and she put me on Copaxone. I had an allergic reaction to it so that only lasted two weeks.
I have been off treatment for a year now, and feel better than I had, although I am now unable to decrease any of the psychiatric meds due to a recurrence in symptoms (both depression and neuropathy). My neurologist now says that treatment is not an option with Rebif or Betaseron due to the side effect of increased depression, so the next episode that comes will leave me with only the option of Tysabri.
depression and MS
Depression was my first symptom of MS, which came on after 50 years old. I am an MD, know the definition, signs and symptoms, and had never had depression before in 50 years, so I believe there is a very high possibility it was directly caused by the disease. Since I did not know I had MS, it was not caused by the awareness of having a chronic disease.
depression and ms
Because of the leakage from the neurons from the lesions, certain neurotransmitters don't work as well (or are released/not released at inappropriate times, or very little is released to be effective to keep emotional homeostasis--like insulin with diabetes). It happens whenever it wants to, and especially more often when exposed to increased stressful experiences. It's unfair and sucks. But, there are effective medications to "keep things in check" as a sort of kick-start, until a more effective program can help without the meds (meditation, yoga, exercise, psychotherapy, etc). Even dietary changes can help. Sometimes though, the meds might have to be taken for the rest of your life because the affliction is uncontrollable conventionally--like with myself. Lastly, never try to "self medicate." That's a very bad idea and can/will make things much worse (i.e. drinking alcohol without moderation, smoking cigarettes (which upregulates glutamine to neurotoxic levels), taking drugs without Rx, etc).
Dietary Changes
What dietary changes can be made to improve depression?
Dietary changes, depression and M.S.
Hi Cheryl and all
Diet doesn't cause depressive symptoms amd thus cannot cure it, but may become a trigger for increased levels of depression.
If you over eat, then put on weight as a consequence you may well get more depressed because you are getting fatter. On the other hand, if you stop eating and become anorexic you will just have developed another problem. Therefore I submit that inappropriate eating (too much or too little) is often a symptom of depression and possibly linked to a need for comfort or self denial/punishment in more severe depression.
I am a psychologist (or I was in my former pre-MS life) who specialized in depression and predicting depression proneness.
Something that others often miss about this MonSter is that depression, often characterized by feelings of helplessness and hopelessness, is a fairly logical response to a chronic, degenerative disease that strikes without warning at the worst possible times.
A better question is if you are not depressed (at least at some level) by our situation then why not?
A trigger for my M.S. exacerbations is feeling unable to DO anything to assist my situation, caught in a catch 22 conundrum where there is nothing I can do to extract myself from the situation which is oppressing me. For example, having a manipulative powerful person in the workplace who deliberately undermined my efforts to achieve anything and used my condition against me. I could see no way out and further unhealthy, unrelenting stress by remaining in that position, so I withdrew from the workplace and sued the perpetrators for disability discrimination which I 'won'.
I did this as a point of principle, attempting to protect others who may be victimized by them in the future. Whilst I can lie straight in bed with my actions the resultant 3.5 years of legal wrangling ended in a shallow victory that destroyed my health and launched me into the Secondary Progressive phase of M.S.
Was it worth it, probably not, but it was emotionally necessary for me. I don't believe people like that should be rewarded for bad behaviour, so someone needed to stick up for their victims (I was only one of many) and publically draw attention to their actions.
Would I do it again with the power of hindsight? Yes, but a lot smarter, with better media coverage and with a different lawyer.
Dietary Changes
Hi Cathy, I didn't think that dietary changes could help with depression but thought I'd ask "Anonymous" since they had made the comment. I was curious...
Good for you for getting out of a bad situation... That "win" must have felt great!!
I have noticed an underlying level of depression (and an increase of 20 lbs over the past year) - not sure if it's due to the MS, the MS medication or personal issues (or all of the above).
Have thought about talking to someone but that means facing reality and not sure I'm up for that right now...
Depression
I was diagnosed with depression before I was diagnosed with MS. I truly believe that the depression was a symptom of my MS. Since lesions are in the brain tissue, it seems to me that it would be pretty common for a disruption in brain chemistry. Which more than likely causes an imbalance to occur causing depression.
MS and depression
both betaseron and avonex really worsened the depression, but avonex was by far the worst. The antidepressants increase fatigue and motivation. Between a rock and a hard place.